Month Three: Kickstarter vs Direct Preorders, and Why We Picked One

BIP Month Three. Three weeks of comparing Kickstarter, Indiegogo, and direct preorders for our launch. The numbers, the platform fees, the audience math, the regulatory side, and the call we ended up making.

Cover: A hand pouring coffee beans with a scoop into a bag
Cover: generic coffee beans being scooped (stock photo).
// editor's note
This is a historical build-in-public entry from April 2026. The brand launch described here is on hold: HexRoast is currently a coffee journal, no product is for sale, and no preorder is open. The entry is kept as a journal record, with its forward-looking launch promises removed.

This is BIP-03 — the third monthly build-in-public report. Month one was about getting started. Month two was about choosing a roasting partner. Month three was about deciding how to launch the actual products: Kickstarter, Indiegogo, or direct preorders on our own site.

If you have not read the previous BIP reports, you can start at month one. If you have, you know that we spent most of February locked in a spreadsheet trying to model these three options against each other. This post is what we found and what we picked.

/ 01The numbers, first

Per the BIP tradition, we start with the actual numbers from month three before any narrative.

Waitlist signups (cumulative)
389 (month-end). Up from 247 last month. Net +142, or roughly 4.7 signups per day.
Field Notes blog launched
Fourth week of the month. 3 posts published in the first few days. Referral traffic data for the companion blog was not published in a later BIP entry.
Site visitors
~5,400 unique (Cloudflare Web Analytics). Up from 2,800 last month.
Email open rate
54% across two BIP-update emails. Click-through 18%. These are unusually high — to be expected for an early waitlist.
Hours spent on launch decision
Roughly 30 hours of research, calls, and modeling spread across three weeks.
Dollars spent
Still $10.88 on the domain. $0 on advertising. $0 on Kickstarter consultants (we considered hiring one and decided no).

/ 02What the three options actually look like

// 02.1Kickstarter

The big platform. ~5% platform fee plus 3-5% payment processing, all-or-nothing funding (you set a target; if you don't hit it, no funds change hands and backers are not charged), strong brand recognition, mature backer infrastructure, decent press attention for funded projects.

Pro: Built-in audience that browses Kickstarter looking for projects. Project virality is real if you hit early momentum. The "Project We Love" curation can drive significant traffic. Trust is high — backers expect Kickstarter projects to ship eventually, even with delays.

Con: The food/beverage category is competitive and fee structure is the same as for hardware. Coffee margins are thinner than the products that traditionally do well on Kickstarter (cookware, tabletop games, gadgets). The platform takes meaningful effort to "do well" on — campaign video, pre-launch list building, daily updates, backer comments management.

// 02.2Indiegogo

Smaller platform, lower brand recognition, but more flexible — supports both fixed and flexible funding (flexible means you keep funds even if you don't hit the target). Fees are similar to Kickstarter (~5% + payment processing).

Pro: The flexible funding option is meaningfully different from Kickstarter's all-or-nothing. For a first-time brand, this reduces the binary risk of campaign failure. Indiegogo also allows continued post-campaign sales through "InDemand," which Kickstarter only added later and less smoothly.

Con: The audience is smaller than Kickstarter's. The platform's reputation has been damaged by some high-profile failed campaigns over the years. Backers tend to be more skeptical, which means harder conversion.

// 02.3Direct preorders

Run our own preorder campaign on hexroast.com using Stripe and a custom-built campaign page. We control everything: pricing, fees (just Stripe's ~2.9% + 30¢), customer relationship, data, timing.

Pro: Highest margin per unit because no platform fees. Full ownership of the customer email and purchase data. We can run the campaign on our timeline and adjust as we learn. The customer relationship is direct from day one — we are not on someone else's platform with someone else's rules.

Con: No built-in audience. We must drive every visitor ourselves. No social proof from a public funding bar. No press from "successfully funded on Kickstarter" framing. If the campaign fails or feels small, we have to manage that publicly without the cover of a platform.

/ 03The framework we ended up using

After three weeks of going back and forth, we organized the decision around four questions:

// 03.1Who is our actual audience?

Our waitlist at the time (389 people) and our content readers (5k+ monthly) are mostly developers and designers. They came to us through technical content, not through coffee discovery. Kickstarter's coffee-curious audience would not be additive to our core audience — it would be a different audience that converts at a worse rate, because we are talking to them in a vocabulary they do not share.

This was the biggest factor. Kickstarter's value is the audience it brings. If the audience it brings is not our audience, the platform fee buys nothing of value.

// 03.2What is our launch goal?

We are not trying to maximize launch revenue. We are trying to validate that the people who follow our content will actually buy our product. A small, high-conversion-rate launch tells us much more than a larger campaign with diluted signal.

This pointed toward direct preorders. Our existing audience converting at 3-5% (a reasonable benchmark for a warm list) gives us the answer we need without external traffic muddying the data.

// 03.3What can we afford to lose?

Both Kickstarter and Indiegogo carry real risk: a public campaign that visibly underperforms damages the brand. With 389 people on the list at the time, we were in a position where a soft public failure would meaningfully hurt the next year of growth.

Direct preorders have the same downside risk in absolute terms, but the failure is much less visible. If our preorder campaign sells 30 units instead of 100, we know it but the public does not. We can iterate without a permanent record.

// 03.4What does month four through twelve look like?

The launch is one month. The relationship with customers from launch lasts much longer. Direct preorder customers are our customers. Kickstarter backers are Kickstarter's customers who happen to have backed our project — Kickstarter owns the email, controls the messaging, and shapes the relationship.

For a brand we had planned to operate for a long time, owning the customer relationship from day one was, at the time, worth a meaningful amount of money in fees we would not pay.

/ 04What we picked

At the time, the choice recorded here was direct preorders over a crowdfunding platform.

That campaign did not launch. The brand launch is on hold, no preorder is open, and no tiers or prices apply. The framework in this entry — audience fit, launch goal, downside risk, and post-launch relationship — is kept here as journal content, not as an offer.

No campaign infrastructure, conversion numbers, or post-mortem were published, because the launch was put on hold. Readers should not expect a BIP-04 campaign report.

/ 05What we are not saying

This is not a "Kickstarter is bad" post. Kickstarter is excellent for the right product, the right audience, and the right business. For a hardware product targeting a tabletop-game crowd, or a kitchenware product targeting design enthusiasts, Kickstarter is probably the right call. For us, the audience math did not work.

If you are building an indie brand and trying to make this same call, the framework above is more useful than our specific answer. Audience fit, launch goal, downside risk, post-launch relationship. Reason from those four. The platform conclusion follows.

/ 06What's next

Month four did not become a preorder execution month. The launch was put on hold, and this journal continues as a coffee journal instead.

Thank you to everyone who read along in month three. There is no preorder, no bonus slot, and no campaign email to wait for.

// keep reading

More coffee writing in this section — no signup, no preorder, just the journal.

More in Community →
// filed under
build in public crowdfunding Kickstarter indie brand launch coffee business crowdfunding BIP-03 indie hacker hexroast